Tuesday, September 8, 2015

Thoughts on John 1:4-5


In John 1:4-5 we come face to face with the literary chain of sorites,[1] (life, life, light, light, darkness, and darkness).[2] These expand on the Word’s participation in creation in this context; later John will expand to salvation, but not here.[3] Notice in creation He is the source of life, his first creative act was light, and the existing darkness was not able to overtake the light. The context of these verses is creation centered. There are three features of the work of Christ in creation:
  • Life—“In Him was life, and the life was the Light” (1:4). There is a parallel to the self-existing life of the Godhead in John 5:26. Life was not created rather it was given (cf. Genesis 2:7; Acts 17:25). There are two clear implications: First, Christ is the life source. Christ empowered the creation with life. He is the source of all life. Second, and somewhat difficult to understand is that His life shared became light, for His “life was the Light of men.” The article used with light in this context is Anaphoric, meaning it is an amplification of life.[4]  Carson correctly states: 
If 1:4...is read in the context of the first three verses, it is more likely that the life inhering in the word is related not to salvation but to creation. The self-existing life of the word was so dispensed at creation that it became the light of the human race...At least in this verse, John is more interested in the source of light (the life of the word) and its purpose (for the human race) than in the mode or purpose of its dispersal.[5]
MacLeod makes three suggestions on this life as light:[6] First, the given life gave significant light in that it was the communication of the knowledge of God. Second, it could be the reflection of God that is seen in His creation (natural or general revelation). Romans 1:20. Third, it is the direct communication that the Lord had with Adam and Eve in the garden. I favor the first suggestion which indicates that there is something in man that knows there is a supreme being—the image of God. From it man has the natural illumination of reason and conscience, insufficient as that may be to bring one to the point of salvation—cf. Romans 2:15.
  • Light—“The Light shines in the darkness” (1:5a). Notice that the word “shines” is in the present tense, indicating that innate light of creation still is active in man. It continues in spite of man’s rebellion/darkness. This is a clear allusion to the fall (Genesis 3). “The light shone in the darkness of the act of creation, and it continues to shine in the darkness of fallen humanity.”[7] This light anticipates the greater light of the Incarnate Christ and the light He gives in salvation (John 1:14). Harris notes “The question of whether John has in mind here the pre-incarnate Christ or the incarnate Christ is probably too specific.”[8] John is using the old creation to set up the light which shines in the work of Jesus Christ.
  • Darkness—“The darkness did not comprehend it.” Darkness in John is positive evil and it speaks of being the environment of the lost. In the plan of God, darkness cannot overtake the power of light. There has been debate over the translation of comprehend. The Greek word is katalambano, meaning to grasp, obtain, to lay hold of, overtake, apprehend, or comprehend. Many take the word to indicate that it has no power to overtake the light and suggest a better translation would be “overpower.” Darkness cannot penetrate or extinguish the light. This statement is in the aorist tense indicating that the failure of overpowering took place in the point of time—at the Cross.




[1]  Sorites: an argument consisting of propositions so arranged that the predicate of any one forms the subject of the next and the conclusion unites the subject of the first proposition with the predicate of the last. (Merrian-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, 11th Edition). It is sometimes referred to as the paradox of the heap, for the Greek word means heap.
[2]  Craig Keener, THE GOSPEL OF JOHN, [Peabody MA, Hendrickson, 2003], 1:383.
[3]  MacLeod, “The Creation of the Universe by the Word: John 1:3-5,” 197.
[4]  See Daniel Wallace, GREEK GRAMMAR: BEYOND THE BASICS, [Grand Rapids MI, Zondervan, 1996], 217-220.
[5]  D,A, Carson, PNTC: THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO JOHN, [Grand Rapids MI, Eerdmans, 1991], 119.
[6]  MacLeod, ‘The Creation of the Universe by the Lord: John 1:3-5,” BIBLIOTHECA SACRA, January 2003, 197-198.
[7]  George Beasley-Murray, WBC: JOHN, [Waco TX, Word, 1987], 11.
[8]  Harris, JOHN, [1:5], www.Bible.org, n.p. 

No comments:

Post a Comment